5 · Nationalism, Kingdom & Dominion
"My kingdom is not of this world. If it were, my servants would fight…" — John 18:36
Few questions divide the Church today like the relationship between faith and nation. Three words sit at the center of the storm, and they are constantly confused: nationalism, Kingdom, and dominion. This chapter tries to define them clearly, order them rightly, and leave room to disagree where Scripture leaves room.
Let us name the danger plainly and the caution alongside it. The danger is idolatry — fusing the cross with a flag until the nation, not Christ, becomes the object of ultimate loyalty. The caution is that the cure for bad politics is not no politics: the gospel has public consequences, and love of one's home and people can be a real and good thing. We are after the narrow, costly road between political idolatry and political apathy.
Three words, carefully defined
- **Patriotism**Healthy love of one's country and people, grateful and self-critical, that does not claim ultimate loyalty.— love of one's land, neighbors, and heritage. A good and ordinary affection, like love of family.
- **Nationalism**An ideology that fuses national and (often) religious identity into an ultimate loyalty, frequently defining the nation against an out-group.— and especially Christian nationalism, which merges Christian identity with national identity and seeks to privilege one religious-cultural group as the nation's true owners.
- **The Kingdom of God**The reign of God in Christ; see Chapter 1. It transcends and judges every nation and cannot be identified with any.— God's reign, which transcends every nation (Chapter 1).
- **Dominion**In Genesis, the human vocation to steward creation under God. Distinct from 'dominionism,' the political project of Christian control over civil society.— the Genesis vocation to steward creation; not to be confused with dominionism, the program of seizing control of government and culture for the Church.
Declare
Where we are
Across many nations — not one — movements now blend religious and national identity into a single cause: our country belongs to our religion, and to be a true citizen is to belong to the right faith and people. Sometimes this wears explicitly Christian dress ("Christian nationalism"); the same idolatrous shape appears in other religions and lands too.
The appeal is understandable. People feel cultural ground shifting, traditions mocked, and communities frayed, and they long for moral order and belonging. Those longings are not evil. But the nationalist answer makes a fatal move: it takes the Church's ultimate allegiance — owed to Christ alone — and gives it to a nation, an ethnicity, or a strongman who promises to defend "us" against "them." History shows where that road leads: the gospel becomes a tribal banner, the stranger becomes an enemy, and the Church loses the very distinctiveness that made it salt and light.
The opposite error is real too: a privatized faith that shrugs at injustice and says the gospel has nothing to do with how we order our common life. Scripture will let us rest in neither error.
What Scripture says
Jesus was offered the kingdoms of the world and the way of political power — and he refused both.
Matthew 4:8-10NIV John 18:36NIVHe taught a dual but unequal loyalty: give the state its due, but give God what belongs to God — and we belong to God.
Mark 12:13-17NIVThe Church's true citizenship is in heaven, and it is one new people drawn from every nation — so no nation can claim to be God's nation now.
Philippians 3:20NIV Revelation 7:9-10NIVYet Scripture also tells exiles to seek the welfare of the city where God has placed them, and to honor governing authorities — while obeying God first when the two conflict.
Jeremiah 29:7NIV Romans 13:1-7NIV Acts 5:29NIVAnd the book of Revelation unmasks every empire that demands worship — calling it "Babylon" — and summons God's people to faithful, non-violent witness rather than to seize the beast's power for themselves.
Revelation 13:1-10NIVDiscern
How should Christians engage public life? Here faithful believers genuinely differ, and these traditions can sharpen one another.
Two Kingdoms
God rules the "left hand" (civil order, through reason and law) and the "right hand" (the Church, through the gospel) in distinct ways. Christians serve in both but must not collapse them. Strength: guards against theocracy. Caution: can under-sell the gospel's public claims.
Transformationist (Kuyperian)
"There is not one square inch of all creation over which Christ does not cry: Mine!" Christians are called to bring every sphere — art, work, politics — under Christ's lordship. Strength: takes culture seriously. Caution: can slide toward triumphalism if it forgets the cross.
Anabaptist / witness
The Church's first political act is to be the Church — a community of peace that shows the world an alternative, wary of running the empire. Strength: keeps the cross central. Caution: can under-engage the structures that shape neighbors' lives.
Catholic social teaching
A rich tradition of the common good, human dignity, subsidiarity, and solidarity, engaging public life through principled participation. Strength: deep and consistent. Caution: requires wisdom to apply in contested cases.
Where declaration replaces debate
These traditions disagree about how to engage — and that's legitimate. None of them blesses Christian nationalism: the fusion of the gospel with national or ethnic supremacy, the use of state coercion to privilege one religious group, or the claim that any earthly nation is God's chosen people in Christ's place. That is not a fourth valid option; it is idolatry, and the Church across its traditions has the resources to name it as such.
Reflect
Be honest: when your faith and your political or national identity conflict, which one usually bends? What would it look like to let Christ's lordship genuinely outrank your tribe?
Of the four traditions above, which most shapes you — and which one's caution do you most need to hear right now?
Self-check
What is the difference between patriotism and (Christian) nationalism?
How does the Bible's 'dominion' differ from 'dominionism'?
Go deeper
- Read next: Advocacy & Public Witness — how the Church can engage public life faithfully.
- Connect back: This chapter depends on The Kingdom of God.
- Scripture for a week: Daniel 1–6 (faithful witness in a pagan empire); Revelation 18 (the fall of "Babylon").
- See the Glossary for nationalism, dominionism, two kingdoms, and common good.
Progress is saved privately in your browser and shown on the home page.